What was in those censored drug stories at ETHS?

Pages 6 and 7 of The Evanstonian's Sept. 22 issue

A two-page spread in Evanston Township High School’s student newspaper about marijuana usage led to a confiscation of the paper by school officials. We’ve examined the content of the offending articles and can now report on what they say.

The drug stories took up most of pages 6 and 7 of The Evanstonian’s  Sept. 22 issue and were presented under an overall heading titled “The pot thickens…”

Noting that the legalization of marijuana is a controversial issue, the series of articles is preceded by a statement that “with a resolution in the state legislature and a growing population of weed smokers in Evanston, we take a look at the pros and cons of legalization, the motives behind recreational use, and the ways in which marijuana affects students.”

The lead article, by Adam Marquardt, examines a bill in the Illinois legislature that predicts increased revenue for the state of $700 million from marijuana legalization that would help the state trim a $64 billion budget deficit “that has caused major problems for Illinois schools.”

The article noted that Evanston “decriminalized” marijuana in an ordinance in 2011, “but only the state has the power to fully legalize the drug.”

A second article, by Ella Kanter and Sophia Weglarzz, is based upon interviews with ETHS students who have tried marijuana and continue to use the drug, even though “marijuana can be damaging to their health.”

The article, headlined “School stress causes marijuana usage,” quotes students who have “smoked weed” in an effort to determine why they do it.

It reasons that “overloaded with AP classes and extensive homework assignments, students often look to marijuana to relieve stress.”

It quotes a sophomore boy as saying “Smoking weed is euphoric. You feel like you’re in this constant state of just simplicity.”

The vast majority of students don’t come to school high, the article states, but there are some students who do.

A senior girl was quoted as saying “I come to school high probably like three to five days a week.”

The article says that “students are generally taught about the science and consequences of weed rather than the firsthand experiences of being high.”

The article concludes that “whether for fun, to relieve stress, or to be part of a distinct culture at ETHS, all agree that marijuana should only be used with proper awareness of its effects.”

In an article headlined “6 Questions for a drug dealer,” by Adam Marquardt, the following six questions were presumably asked of a drug dealer:

How long have you been dealing and why?

How often do you sell?

Where do you get the marijuana you sell?

How do you distribute?

Do you feel safe selling?

How much do you make?

An article by Rachel Krumholz carries the headline, “Teens seek marijuana for medical purposes.”

It quotes a number of studies that explain how marijuana is used to reduce pain and anxiety and notes that an Illinois resident must be 18 years of age to obtain a medical marijuana card.

The article concludes with an internet link to a website that gives “more information on the benefits of marijuana.”

A sidebar gives apparent results of a student survey on marijuana without any details of how or where the survey was conducted. It says that 67 percent of ETHS students have smoked weed, that 37.2 percent of students have been high during school, that 27.9 percent of students have gotten high at ETHS, and that 4.5 percent of students spend more than fifty dollars a week on weed.

The administration, in its statement last week, said that the school was justified in confiscating the copies on the grounds that “when student journalism incites unlawful acts, violation of school policy, or disrupts the school, the administration has the authority to impose limits. The articles on September 22, 2017 did cross these lines and were removed from circulation for that reason.”

The student journalists who spoke during the Public Comment portion of last week’s District 202 Board meeting, contended that the purpose of the articles was not to condone marijuana use but was intended to inform student readers about why some students use marijuana and how prevalent it is at ETHS.

They disagreed with the administration’s assessment that the articles cross the line legally into territory that permits the confiscation of the newspapers.

Related story:

ETHS in legal hot water with student journalists

 

Topic: 

Comments

Stop Censorship in Evanston

The ETHS administrators owe the public a much more detailed explanation for why they banned the student newspaper, and if they plan to break state law in order to censor it in the future.

According to the Student Press Law Center (which has a slightly more readable scan of the articles, http://www.splc.org/article/2017/10/illinois-high-school-confiscates-student-paper-over-marijuana-story) the student journalists are allowing the administration to impose anti-marijuana content.

Considering that the stories quote a health teacher, and a drug dealer who was a victim of armed robbery, it's hard to see how any of these articles were pro-marijuana, and even if they had been, supporting something is not the same as incitement.

I believe the Supreme Court

I believe the Supreme Court settled this type high school paper free speech issue a long time ago. What is wrong with these people(administrators)? These articles appear to be well done btw and not "fake" news -although the statistical methods of the survey should have been provided.

The Supreme Court decided on this

Yes, the Supreme Court decided on this in Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier. And ETHS would have won this case had it gone to court. HS newspapers are subject to a lower threshold when it comes to free speech. The HS administration/school has the right to control content in the newspaper, especially if it deems that the content promotes violation of rules/laws--which, by my reading, it does.


Do you rely on Evanston Now for local news? Support independent journalism by becoming an Evanston Now member. Contribute monthly or just once.

Become a member