Aldermen on Evanston’s Human Services Committee balked Monday at offering support for a resolution that would encourage the state legislature to legalize medical aid in dying.

The resolution was proposed by Evanston residents who are members of a national organization called Compassion & Choices, which seeks to expand the number of states that permit a terminally ill, mentally capable adult to ask his or her physician for a prescription for medication that the patient may choose to take to end their pain and suffering and bring about a peaceful death.

Oregon became the first state to adopt a death with dignity or physician-assisted suicide law in 1997. It’s been joined by six other states and the District of Columbia, with Hawaii becoming the most recent addition to the list last April.

Fay Clayton of Compassion & Choices said the laws have strict safeguards and that there have been no reports of abuses in the 21 years since Oregon adopted its statute.

But Alderman Robin Rue Simmons, 5th Ward, said she would be concerned about abuses.

Robin Rue Simmons.

“This is quite a heavy decision,” Rue Simmons said. “I understand it’s just a resolution, just symbolic, but I can’t right now support any steps forward for it.”

Alderman Judy Fiske, 1st Ward, said she felt “totally unqualified to make a decision” on the issue.

Alderman Cicely Fleming, 9th Ward, said believed the city shouldn’t spend time having its legal staff review resolutions on issues that the city doesn’t control “when we’re down two lawyers in our legal department.”

Evanston’s state representative, Robyn Gabel and Laura Fine, both support the legislation, Clayton said, but she said the group has found that the non-binding local resoluations can help prompt state legislatures to act on the issue.

Only Alderman Eleanor Revelle, 7th Ward, who was chairing the meeting, said she supports the resolution, but she said it appeared that “a lot of education needs to be done” before the City Council might be ready to adopt it.

The committee opted not to forward the draft resolution submitted by the group to the city’s legal department for review.

At least for now that halts any move toward having the full City Council adopt the measure.

Bill Smith is the editor and publisher of Evanston Now.

Join the Conversation

1 Comment

  1. thank you Fay Clayton & Eleanor Revelle

    Thank you Fay Clayton
    I’m assuming this is the same famous Fay Clayton who in 1994 on behalf of the National Orginization of Women argued a successful case before the US Supreme Court and received a 9-0 decision.  The case stopped anti-abortion protestors from blocking abortion clinics and threatening patients. 
    She can pursuade the Supreme Court, but not the great minds of the Evanston city council.
    Alderman Judy Fiske said she felt “totally unqualified to make a decision” on the issue.  That has never stopped her before.

    Thank you Eleanor Revelle.  Thank you Eleanor for supporting the “Compassion & Choices” resolution.  In the event that your proposed increase to the property transfer tax proves to be too much for Evanston home owners, it will be nice to have a way out.

Leave a comment
The goal of our comment policy is to make the comments section a vibrant yet civil space. Treat each other with respect — even the people you disagree with. Whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *