Evanston massage zoning plan draws wave of criticism

Dozens of people turned out at the Evanston Civic Center Wednesday night to object to a city staff plan to impose special use restrictions on massage therapists and similar professionals.

The wave of opposition, from therapists themselves and other groups and individuals, initially persuaded three of the six Plan Commissioners present that they should drop the effort to regulate massage through zoning entirely.

But a plea by the commission's chair, Scott Peters, persuaded them to instead defer the issue for further discussion at their July 19 meeting.

Peters, a former prosecutor, said prostitution cases are very difficult to prosecute under criminal law and that zoning codes offer a much easier way to address the problem because standards of proof are much lower and the difficulties of proving a case are much less.

"Maybe all we need is a definition of what a massage establishment is, so that when someone is operating a house of prostitution and pretending to be operating a massage establishment, we can say, you're not meeting the definition and are therefore in violation of the ordinance," Peters said.

"It's quicker, easier and more likely to be successful," he added.

The staff had retreated somewhat by Wednesday night from its original proposal to require all establishments offering massage-like services to go through the city's special use licensing process.

After complaints from the American Massage Therapy Association, which has its headquarters in Evanston, that massage therapists are state-licensed professionals, the staff proposal was revised to exempt them from the special use restrictions.

But it preserved the special use requirements for practitioners of nearly a dozen other body works therapeutic models, including the Shiatsu.

Steve Rogne, owner of Zen Shiatsu Chicago at 825 Chicago Ave., said the professional group he belongs to, the American Organization for Bodywork Therapies of Asia, has been lobbying the state for three years to establish a licensing procedure for his profession.

He suggested that bodyworks professionals could voluntarily submit to the criminal background checks and fingerprinting already required of massage therapists.

And he complained that the ordinance stigmatizes legitimate professionals by claiming that clustering massage and bodyworks establishments would detract from the character of the community.

Nancy Floy, who owns the Heartwood Center on Dempster Street, which houses dozens of professionals in massage, body work and other fields, said she had met Wednesday morning with Police Chief Richard Eddington and wanted to help stop prostitution problems in the city.

"But we don't want our profession to be sacrificed in the name of stopping that," Floy added.

Kaethe Morris Hoffer, legal director of the Chicago Alliance Against Sexual Exploitation, said that rather than using zoning laws, the city should "focus on the true root of prostitution — the demand side, those men who purchase sex."

"It doesn't take a degree in rocket science to figure out where to go to purchase sex," Hoffer said. "If the johns can figure out where to go, so can police and law enforcement agencies."

Dick Peach, the vice president for government affairs of the Evanston chamber of Commerce, said at least 22 chamber members would fall under the proposed ordinance and all are adamantly against it.

"It bothers us that in a community that supposedly is very proud of its small businesses, this ordinance turns around and stomps all over that reputation and impugns very good small businesses."

Jeanne Lindwall of 625 Library Place, a urban planning consultant, said she's thrilled that there are so many massage therapists and body workers in town.

"I've been getting massages over the last 10 to 15 years. They're wonderful," Lindwall said, adding that she doesn't beleave the zoning ordinance is an appropriate mechanism for trying to address prostitution.

"Zoning is about land use," Lindwall said, "Prostitution is an illegal activty and should be dealt with as such."

Two prostitution busts over the past two years at spas or other establishments that claimed to offer massages were the trigger cited by city officials for the proposed new restrictions, which some officials say is part of a larger program to increase regulation of businesses in the city.

Related stories

Evanston eyes tougher massage parlor rules

Massage therapists work over Evanston's proposed rules

Evanston massage rules misguided, therapists say

Related document

City staff memo and proposed ordinance

Editors’ Picks