Members of the Jewish Reconstructionist Congregation in Evanston visited Palestinian homes and Arab and Jewish organizations throughout the West Bank and Israel last month.

Rabbi Brant Rosen says he organized the trip “because I believe it is critical that American Jews make an effort to learn about the Palestinian experience from Palestinians themselves.”

Members of the Jewish Reconstructionist Congregation in Evanston visited Palestinian homes and Arab and Jewish organizations throughout the West Bank and Israel last month.

Rabbi Brant Rosen says he organized the trip “because I believe it is critical that American Jews make an effort to learn about the Palestinian experience from Palestinians themselves.”

Participants ranged from 24 to 75 years old, and included educators, doctors, attorneys and other professionals.

Rosen says most group members had visited Israel multiple times and he wanted them to challenge their understanding of the Middle East conflict by meeting with Palestinian families and civic leaders.

The Dec. 20 to 28 trip was reportedly the first time a Jewish congregational group has stayed overnight in a Palestinian refugee camp. Group members spent two nights in the homes of families in the Deheishe Palestinian refugee camp near Bethlehem.

“After playing with their children, eating with them, and sharing stories about our lives, I’ll never be able to read about violence in the West Bank without picturing the faces of the people we encountered,” said Danny Newman, 33, Chicago-area high school teacher.

Marjorie Frank, 75, former social work professor at Hebrew University in Jerusalem, said, “I’m overwhelmed that I lived in Israel for 14 years and was totally oblivious. I knew Deheishe existed, but experiencing it was overwhelming. The family’s little boy put his arm around me every time I sat down, and we exchanged Facebook addresses.”

Participants visited sites including the Dome of the Rock; Jerusalem neighborhoods including the Arab community of Silwan; Hebron; Tel Aviv; and Jenin, which was the site of intense violence during an Israeli military incursion in 2002.

They met with religious and peace leaders including the Imam of the Al-Aqsa Mosque; a representative of Rabbis for Human Rights; members of the Bereaved Parents Circle and the Jenin Freedom Theater.

The trip was led by Aziz Abu Sarah, a Palestinian peace activist whose brother was killed by the IDF, and Kobi, a Jewish peace activist and former member of Kahane Youth, a Jewish extremist group who spent his youth in a West Bank settlement. Both have lost loved ones to the conflict.

The trip has provoked soul-searching among participants. “This trip has challenged the views that many of us have grown up with and has given us much to think about,” said Michael Shapiro, 72, former president of the Champaign-Urbana Jewish Federation.

Trip participants plan to organize public presentations in the area to share additional information about their experiences.

Join the Conversation

1 Comment

  1. an outstanding, ground-breaking trip

    The news of this trip should be spread widely. Readers might like to take a look at Rabbi Rosen’s blog, Shalom Rav, where an account of the trip with pictures can be found. Just scroll down to find the posts about it. Each one is well worth reading.

    It has only been within the past few years that I have become fully aware of not only the current situation in Israel/Palestine but of the true history of that nation as revealed by Israel’s "new historians". I’m ashamed of the ignorance that allowed me to lead a care-free life of many decades here in America even as my own country using my tax money was (and still is) supporting the continual oppression of the indigenous people over there whose only crime was to live in a place someone else wanted without them in it.

    I wish all Americans could take the itinerary that this group took. The outrage at what is happening and has happened would remake our foreign policy overnight. We can’t go back and make up for what our forebears did to Native-Americans but we surely can avoid financing the same process happening today – the height of hypocrisy for a country that brags of "freedom and justice for all".

    For the armchair traveler, check out the YouTube series Sleepless in Gaza and Jerusalem, pick any of the many half hour episodes and have your eyes opened.

Leave a comment
The goal of our comment policy is to make the comments section a vibrant yet civil space. Treat each other with respect — even the people you disagree with. Whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims.

Your email address will not be published.