A housing advocacy group says it’s settled a federal court suit against a local landlord who tried to limit apartment rentals to Northwestern University students.

The settlement agreement resolves the suit filed under federal fair housing laws against Bernsen Management by the Interfaith Housing Center of the Northern Suburbs.

In a news release, Interfaith said the agreement, reached last month, prohibits Bernsen from engaging in discriminatory practices based upon familial status.

The Bernsens denied the allegations in the suit and the settlement was entered into without an admission of liability.

The case involved an NU student who wanted to sublet the bedroom she was renting in a Bernsen building and questioned the company’s written policy that limited sublets to Northwestern University students and specified that each apartment could be occupied by no more than three roommates.

Interfaith says that when it had testers who said they had families inquire about renting units in the building, Bernsen said the property would not be suitable for them.

While federal law explicitly bars discrimination in housing based on “familial status,” Evanston ordinances require landlords to discriminate on that basis by barring rental of properties to more than three unrelatied individuals while permitting larger groups of related persons to share the same dwelling.

Bill Smith is the editor and publisher of Evanston Now.

Join the Conversation


  1. Why?

    Why would a landlord turn down paying customers?  Wouldn't non-student tenants be easier to deal with than students?

    1. Why? Seems odd

      You alway read of buildings not wanting to rent to students.

      The logic of these owners seems odd. 

      As an owner of a condo, I can understand someone not wanting children because of noise and damage, but then again I'd not buy into a condo that permitted renters. 

      It is hard enough to get owners to become involved in the association and take care of the property. They treat the property like renters and want everything done for them like renters do and I guess assume by the time there is need for repair/replacement, they will have sold. 

      So it is less likely that renters will have even that level of responsibility.

  2. I will be the devil’s

    I will be the devil's advocate: if you are a landlord and in a building you have 20 units, 19 of them rented to undergraduates… would you rent unit # 20 to a family with young children? Probably not: both the students and the family will complain of each other (children running a like a stampede of elephants, rowdy undergrads being loud late at night).

Leave a comment
The goal of our comment policy is to make the comments section a vibrant yet civil space. Treat each other with respect — even the people you disagree with. Whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *