Evanston aldermen got cold feet Monday about plans to renovate the branch libraries.

So they voted to postpone action on a contract to spend $52,500 to hire an architect to design the improvements at the north and south branches.

After learning that the south branch project might cost $300,000, Alderman Steve Bernstein, whose 4th Ward is near the library site, said he thought that was too much to spend when the city has less than four years to go on its lease for the building.

The library’s administrative services manager, Paul Gottschalk, said the city is talking to the landlord about a 10-year lease extension.

But Alderman Ann Rainey, 8th Ward, said she had doubts about the merits of extending the lease “when from time to time we’re confronted with the issue of cutting the library branches.”

Alderman Edmund Moran, 6th Ward, said the council could only get firm estimates of what the project would cost by hiring the architect to design it.

But Alderman Lionel Jean-Baptiste, 2nd Ward, said he feared a repeat of the experience with the children’s section renovation at the main library in which “cost estimates kept going higher and higher and we ended up committing a lot more money than we intended to.”

The proposed work would eliminate accessibility problems, update washrooms, and upgrade electrical and air conditioning systems in the branches.

Some aldermen were also concerned that only part of the funding to do the rehab work is already in place.

The city has allocated $130,000 in this year’s capital improvement plan for the work and pending council approval could add $130,000 more next year. It also expects to receive $50,000 in contributions from library supporters for the project.

But the rest of the money is expected to come from the sale of a city-owned storefront adjacent to the north branch.

While a realtor hired by the city has estimated the sale would bring in $380,000, the building hasn’t actually sold yet.

The library issue will be back on the City Council’s agenda for its next meeting, Oct. 27.

Bill Smith is the editor and publisher of Evanston Now.

Join the Conversation

1 Comment

  1. Council member’s lack of leadership on the branch libraries!
    Last nights council meeting show our public official continue lack of leadership. What is interesting they are going out for a proposal with no clear vision on what they are doing. They complain about using consultants yet they have no clue as to what to tell the consultants to do – thus we waste more money.

    One council member said the North branch library only need lighting – what a bunch of nonsense. The entire building needs a complete renovation. The washrooms are single use – that is the are shared by all – clearly not correct in a public facility. One council member has been pushing the sale of the adjoining building as the big solution to the cash problem.

    I have been stating for four years now that the North Branch building can not be correctly renovated without the use of the adjoining building they wish to sell. What I have heard off the record is one of the bidders (architect) has stated that also, not enough room to create the new bathrooms!

    Anyone with a brain by walking into the North branch can see the entire place needs a complete renovation -it appears the south branch is worst.

    Bottomline it appears the city needs $500,000 to $600,000 – in construction costs if not more – when they have about enough for one building if that.

    Alot of politics out of a few council members – who not know what they are doing.

    What are they likely to do? What they always do – Nothing!

Leave a comment
The goal of our comment policy is to make the comments section a vibrant yet civil space. Treat each other with respect — even the people you disagree with. Whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims.

Your email address will not be published.