Asked about police-community relations, Evanston’s five mayoral candidates Thursday night offered a range of perspectives on where things stand and what needs to be done.

Steve Hagerty said Oct. 10, 2015, when Lawrence Crosby was charged with disobeying police after he was stopped on suspicion of having stolen a car that turned out to be his, “was not one of our finest days.”

But he said he believed the city had learned from that situation, and when last November when Devon Reid was arrested while circulating petitions to run for city clerk, the city “apologized 24-hours later” dropped the charges and suspended two of the officers involved.

“We need to hold folks accountable when mistakes are made,” Hagerty said, “and we do need to double-down on training” on how to descalate confrontations.

Jeff Smith.

Jeff Smith said the police have more than 30,000 contacts with the public a year, including 12,000 to 15,000 traffic stops. And in 2015, he said there was just one complaint of excessive force, and only a few more in 2016.

“If you compare Evanston to other departments,” Smith said, “We’re definitely one of the better departments.”

“And we shouldn’t make policy based on what’s an outlier situation,” he added.

But Alderman Brian Miller said he’s been focused on the issue since being appointed to the City Council. He said police have been disproportionately charging young black men for possession of small amounts of marijuana and charging people riding bikes without lights with resisting arrest.

Some of the roughly 100 people who turned out for the OPAL-sponsored forum at Chute School.

Miller said he pushed for release of the Crosby video after seeing parallels between that and the Reid case. Miller also has called for creation of an independent civilian review panel to investigate the police.

Alderman Mark Tendam said City Council members, after privately seeing the Crosby video, were pushing for reforms in police procedures and said he didn’t feel it was appropriate for him to comment on it publicly while Crosby’s suit against the city was pending.

Gary Gaspard.

Candidate Gary Gaspard said there’s need for a paradigm shift in the way police see young black men and in how those young black men see the police.

The police, he said, see the men as a threat to society or themselves, while the youths see police as exterminators seeking to wipe out the black community.

“We have to try to change that,” Gaspard said, “Not by law but by the way we interact with each other.”

There’ll be more discussion of police-community relations at an open house sponsored by the police department at 7 p.m. Monday at the Levy Center.

Bill Smith is the editor and publisher of Evanston Now.

Join the Conversation


  1. Miller’s dishonesty
    Miller is being dishonest on the bike light issue. There is no evidence of the police charging people riding without bike lights for ‘resisting arrest.’ There was one case where a seemingly intoxicated person was riding a bike without lights–a safety issue that is a violation of city ordinance and state law–was stopped by the police and got belligerent and physically aggressive. It was after the aggression that the police decided to arrest.

    I’ve actually been stopped for riding my bike without a light. The cop questioned me, I answered the questions calmly and in a straightforward manner and was given a warning.

    He also claims to be the one person in all of Evanston who forced the city to release the Crosby tape. Totally sillly. Crosby’s attorneys had the tape and anyone could file a FOIA to obtain a copy. His grandstanding on this is just pathetic.

    1. Miller Honesty
      Actually candidate Miller is telling the truth about those riding a bike with no lights being charged with resisting arrest, and this is first hand information. You will have his detractors say that he is Grandstanding because he is bringing to the forefront the true lack of diversity in Evanston. I state this and i’m not even a candidate Miller supporter.

  2. Learning A Lesson – Devon Reid

    I’m not sure I understand Mayoral Candidate Hagerty’s comment referring to the Crosby over-the-top arrest that he “believed the city had learned from that situation, and when last November when Devon Reid was arrested while circulating petitions to run for city clerk, the city “apologized 24-hours later” dropped the charges and suspended two of the officers involved.”   Why was Devon Reid arrested at all if the city learned a lesson from the Lawrence Crosby situation.  For that matter, it was only after the Crosby tape was released to the public that Mayor Tisdahl made a statement that changes were being made in arrest procedures.  That statement was made after Devon Reid was arrested.

    1. He was arrested at all
      He was arrested at all because he refused to answer the same questions that the other guy who was with him answered, and was promptly let go.

Leave a comment
The goal of our comment policy is to make the comments section a vibrant yet civil space. Treat each other with respect — even the people you disagree with. Whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *