The Evanston City Council tonight will get a recommendation from its Human Services Committee that the city look for a new volunteer group to replace the Community Animal Rescue Effort at the city’s shelter.

The committee voted 3-1 Monday night to end the city’s troubled relationship with CARE.

The vote came after members concluded that CARE’s willingness to euthanize dogs to avoid the risk they might attack people doesn’t match what the aldermen saw as the preference of most residents to see as many dogs as possible rescued and rehabilitated.

“This discussion should have been about what kind of animals the city wants to have in the community and be responsible for ,” CARE board member Gail Lovinger Goldblatt said,

“Sometimes dogs attack other dogs, sometimes dogs bite people, sometimes they maul people, in extraordinary situations they kill people,” Goldblatt added.

Goldblatt also complained about several aspects of a new city policy for shelter operations that the committee also approved Monday night, saying, “This doesn’t feel like a partnership. The arrangement being proposed is one-sided, the volunteer animal organization would have no authority or voice, but is expected to pay for the operation.”

Committee Chair Delores Holmes.

“None of us can predict what’s going to happen” at City Council, Aldeman Delores Holmes, 5th Ward, who chaired the Human Services Committee meeting said.

“Everybody has fault in this,” Holmes added, “the city for too many years didn’t pay as much attention to the shelter as it should have.”

Alderman Mark Tendam, 6th Ward, said he believes the relationship with CARE “is broken beyond repair.”

He said numerous former CARE volunteers came to him over the past few months and said they wanted to be part of animal rescue efforts in the community, but that because of CARE’s policies they felt they could not participate.

Alderman Judy Fiske, 1st Ward, said discussions with CARE had been going on for 15 months. “CARE seems to have a vision for its organization that’s very different from what we must do as a municipal shelter,” Fiske said.

Only Alderman Peter Braithwaite, 2nd Ward, voted against the recommendation to end the city’s relationship with CARE, suggesting instead that the city give CARE until April 28 to decide whether to move forward.

Braithwaite, who said he’d visited the shelter on Saturday, said the issues ultimately involved “two families of volunteers that just could not get along.”

“It’s very disturbing,” he added.

Related stories

CARE gets a week to decide whether to play ball (April 1)

Panel votes to try again with CARE (Mar. 4)

Panel would kick CARE to the curb (Feb. 19)

Dog lovers snap at each other (Feb. 4)

Bill Smith is the editor and publisher of Evanston Now.

Join the Conversation


  1. Right decision, finally

    Sorry, Alderman Braithwaite, this is not about "two families of volunteers who can't get along." It's about a dysfunctional organization whose relationship with the City is broken beyond repair.

    It kills more dogs than just about any shelter in the area, ten times the number of nearby Waukegan. 

    The City gave the CARE leadership chance after chance to work with them to fix things, and over and over they spit in their face. 

    They sent not one but two nasty, evasive letters in response to the City's proposals, and refused to discuss them when the Committee asked what they actually meant. 

    They refused to share their records about City animals with the City.

    They raised money "for the Evanston Animal Shelter" and then hoarded it for some new shelter somewhere else. 

    What's amazing is that the City took this long to show them the door. 

  2. One of Problems with committee

    One of the problems I have with this committee  is that they allow Aldermen Fiske to continue and not excuse herself fomr the conversation on CARE status. This is the second time wondered and why this was going on since last year she held a group meeting about the  beach fence ( promised to look into it )  For those that aren't aware she does own a PET STORE.


    Wasn't totall sure of who was supposed to be in chaare until I saw this EVANSTONNOW ARTICLE.

Leave a comment
The goal of our comment policy is to make the comments section a vibrant yet civil space. Treat each other with respect — even the people you disagree with. Whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *