At least 13 percent of the retail frontage on two major downtown Evanston streets is empty — more than twice the vacancy rate that the city’s Economic Development Committee will be told about in a report at a meeting tonight.

Paul Zalmezak, of the city’s economic development staff, says the 5 percent first quarter citywide retail vacancy figure that the city gets from the subscription real estate data provider CoStar counts only properties that are on the market and for which no one is currently paying rent.

Often, after a store shutters, the company that leased the space continues to pay rent on the empty store for a time, Zalmezak says, and CoStar adds those spaces to its vacancy rate to come up with what it calls the “availability rate” — which current stands at 9.3 percent for downtown Evanston.

CoStar calculates its figures based on the square footage of spaces that are on the market from a survey of 64 buildings in the city.

In compiling our figures, Evanston Now looked at what’s most obvious to passersby — the amount of retail street frontage that’s empty.

Given limited resources, we were only able to look at the two east-west streets — Church Street and Davis Street — from the 500 to 1100 blocks.

What we found was that 13 new businesses have opened on the two streets since the start of 2016 and two more businesses have signs up announcing planned openings.

Title Boxing Club, just opening on Davis Street.

But 10 businesses have closed on the two streets within that time span and 11 properties that were vacant when 2016 started are still vacant now.

Also noted on the map, ownership changes for two major office buildings — one on Church, the other on Davis.

Adding up the estimated street frontage for just retail storefronts, we found that just under 13 percent of the nearly 3,600 feet of retail frontage on Davis Street is vacant, along with over 14 percent of the 2,000 square feet of retail frontage on Church Street.

Since the start of 2016, new businesses have opened in just under 9 percent of the frontage on Davis and 6.6 percent of the frontage on Church.

At this point it looks like openings are gaining on closings.

And the just-concluded first quarter is the time of year when a lot of struggling merchants decide to pack it in, if they were disappointed with their results from the traditionally strong fourth quarter holiday season.

So it’s possible that the opening/closing figures may look even better later in the year.

One thing the CoStar data offers is a head-to-head comparison with other communities. And comparing communities, CoStar says that the retail vacancy rate in Evanston is nearly two percentage points lower than the rates for Chicago’s Loop and the rest of the north suburbs.

Bill Smith is the editor and publisher of Evanston Now.

Leave a comment

The goal of our comment policy is to make the comments section a vibrant yet civil space. Treat each other with respect — even the people you disagree with. Whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *