Fire calls double during the day, but staffing stays the same

A union sign opposing the proposed closure of Fire Station 4.

Evanston's fire and ambulance crews respond to twice as many calls during the daytime hours than they do at night, but the city's 24-hour duty schedule for firefighters means staffing doesn't vary with the predictable shift in demand.

Calls for service data provided by Fire Chief Brian Scott at Evanston Now's request show that the number of calls for Evanston's five fire engines, two trucks and two ambulances range from a low of one call every two hours in the pre-dawn darkness to more than one-and-a-half calls per hour at mid-day.

Roughly two out of every three calls are ambulance runs. In addition to an ambulance, a fire engine is dispatched for every ambulance call.

While police officers in Evanston work eight-hour shifts, permitting variation in staffing during different day parts, the 24-hour schedule for firefighters precludes that option.

That scheduling pattern for the fire service is very common across the country, although a variety of other schedules, including eight and 12 hour shifts and split 10 and 14 hour shifts are also in use.

Some reports have raised questions about the health and safety impact of working 24-hour long shifts. And reports are mixed about which pattern is most efficient from a scheduling and overtime standpoint.

Fire department data shows that Evanston's ambulances are by far the most heavily used vehicles in the Evanston fire fleet.

Ambulance 21 is on calls nearly 29 percent of the time, while Truck 23 is in use less than 7 percent of the time.

The Village of Glenview has come up with a partial solution to the varying level of demand across different day parts.

It runs two ambulances 24-hours a day and staffs a third ambulance for 12 hours each day -- from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m.

Glenview's department serves a population of about 60,000 people in the village and adjacent unincorporated areas with four engines and one truck in addition to its ambulances.

Evanston's Chief Scott says a third ambulance would help reduce call volume for the existing two ambulances "which are extremely busy."

But he says given the current budget deficit it would be extremely difficult to fund the addition of even 12 more hours of ambulance service.

City Manager Wally Bobkiewicz has proposed closing Fire Station 4, which would elminate the jobs of nine firefighters.

If instead of closing the station, which now houses an engine, an ambulance operating for 12 hours a day were stationed there, it would make it possible to reduce the impact of the loss of the engine on service levels while still eliminating six of the nine firefighter jobs proposed to be cut.

Evanston aldermen will hold a special meeting on the 2019 budget Saturday morning at 9 a.m. at the Civic Center.

Related stories

Topic: 

Comments

But wait....

Where is data for Ambulance 23? As I understand it, it is out of service when Engine 23 is in service and vice versa. Is the low useage for E23 reflective of the fact that the crew is on the ambulance?

Also the idea of an ambulance at station 24 instead of an engine could be a step in the right direction.