The Evanston story that seems to never go away — what to do with the city-owned Harley Clarke mansion on the Lake Michigan shoreline — will return to the news this year with groups hoping to lease the property due to submit proposals for its restoration and use by Feb. 28.

The Evanston Lakehouse group, whose proposal to lease the mansion was turned down by the city in 2018 over concerns the group lacked the financial resources to get the renovations done, has indicated it plans to submit a new proposal by the February deadline.

The non-profit group, which has 22 members on its board, has been quiet about its fundraising efforts in recent months. Its officers include President Emily Guthrie, Vice President Patrick Donnelly, Secretary Allie Harned and Treasurer Nancy Sreenan.

Reports the group has submitted to the IRS indicate that it took in no more than $50,000 in each of its last four fiscal years, including the one that ended last June.

The group changed its formal name on state records from “Evanston Lake House and Gardens Inc. NFP” to “Evanston Community Lakehouse and Gardens, Inc.” last August.

Another group that would like to see the mansion restored, Friends of Harley Clarke, registered with the state in December 2018 and reported to the IRS that it raised $5,365 that year. It listed its board members as Jennifer Shadur, Jill Zordan, Charles Smith and Susan Aaron.

The group’s website currently reports raising a total of $18,001.69 in 64 donations toward a $100,000 goal.

Its Facebook page reports a separate fundraising effort last month raising $975 toward a $5,000 goal.

Last April Zordan filed incorporation papers with the state for a new group called the Friends of Harley Clarke and Jens Jensen Gardens. It has not yet filed a financial report with the IRS.

And there’s the Jens Jensen Gardens in Evanston, Inc., a not-for-profit registered with the state last May that lists Guthrie as its agent and is focused on restoring the original landscape that surrounds the mansion.

It doesn’t list any fundraising accomplishments on its website and does not show up in a search of tax exempt organizations on the IRS website.

Then there’s Audrey Niffenegger, the author of The Time Traveler’s Wife and other novels, who said last November that she’s hoping to submit a plan in February to turn the mansion into an Artists Book House.

She’s collected a board with a dozen members and says on the group’s Facebook page that she’s recently filed paperwork to win not-for-profit status with the IRS. No details yet on what funds the book house group has raised.

How much funds a potential new tenant for the mansion will have to provide to win a lease from the city is unclear. But cost estimates for upgrading the property have ranged widely — from hundreds of thousands to several million dollars — depending on the scope of the work.

Related stories

Bill Smith is the editor and publisher of Evanston Now.

Leave a comment

The goal of our comment policy is to make the comments section a vibrant yet civil space. Treat each other with respect — even the people you disagree with. Whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims.