After 25 years of serving coffee and donuts to commuters at Evanston’s Central Street Metra station, the popular “Top of the Tracks” will pour its last cup Friday morning as owner Mary Lou Smith heads into retirement.

An Evanston native and graduate of Evanston Township High School, Smith’s café was filled with well-wishers Thursday morning, including one who brought a bouquet of flowers.

It quickly became apparent that Smith not only knows most of her customers by name, but she knows what they want. Hardly anybody had to place an order.

With a wink and a smile, she warned them that when the new owners come in on Monday, assuming that inspections by the city go well, the customers will have to tell them what they want.

But Smith has been dispensing more than breakfast items over the years. She has also become a central point for discussions of news pertaining to residents of north Evanston, who have counted on her to keep them posted on changes in the area.

Mary Lou Smith dispenses news along with coffee and baked goods.

“I understand the city shot down McDonald’s,” said one customer, referring to a proposed fast-food restaurant on Gross Point Road and Old Orchard Road.

“I hear a restaurant’s going into the Ubaa,” said another, in reference to a popular Skokie bar on Crawford Avenue that went out of business a year or so ago.

Smith gives a great deal of credit to her husband, Bill (no relation to the publisher of Evanston Now), a retired Evanston police officer who wakes up at 2:30 every morning to pick up the bagels and donuts and make the coffee before the first train arrives around 5 a.m.

“The train’s engineers and conductors call ahead with their orders,” she said, “and Bill meets them on the platform with their food.”

Mary Lou arrives at 6 a.m., and her fast-moving day begins. There’s a certain rhythm to her day, as customers begin to arrive as time for the next train approaches. Then they board the train and all is quiet until time for the next train.

Occasionally a friend or two will come and sit in one of the booths or tables and chat with Mary Lou as she works, but most of the time the customers grab their food and disappear into the station waiting room or the platform outside. The café closes after the last train leaves around 10 a.m.

The routine changes during a hotly fought local election, she says, as news crews and leaflet-distributing candidates alter the atmosphere. Occasionally a candidate will order free coffee for all the commuters, and then activity really picks up, she says.

Particularly memorable was the day after the Sept. 11, 2001, tragedy at the World Trade Center buildings in New York. Television news crews showed up to interview commuters about the attack, she said.

Because she has so many regulars, Mary Lou has come to know many of them personally, including the health of their spouses and some unrepeatable details of their love lives. Once she held a party in the depot for the many adult singles that had lost their spouses through death or divorce.

She’s now looking to expand a part-time business of staging houses for sale, but in the meantime, she says she may come back to the station and hand out invitations to a BYOB party for her customers at the newly opened Curt’s Café on Central Street.

But first, she has some sleep to catch up on.

Charles Bartling

A resident of Evanston since 1975, Chuck Bartling holds a master’s degree in journalism from Northwestern University and has extensive experience as a reporter and editor for daily newspapers, radio...

Join the Conversation


  1. Mary Lou Smith for 6th ward alderperson!

    Mary Lou should run for 6th ward alderperson, we need at least one adult on the City Council.

  2. Continuation ?

    I'd heard a couple of months ago that three women had bought the cafe and would continue it.

    Did that fall through or is there just a new name for the place ?

  3. The new owners

    Smith told me she had sold the business to three women who planned to take over on Monday, as the story said, pending approvals from city inspectors. Although she sold the name along with the business, it was her understanding that the new owners planned to operate the cafe, with some modifications, under a new name.

  4. Thanks for your service!

    Good Luck Mary Lou!  Thanks for the coffee!

    Dan Mennemeyer
    Past President
    Evanston Chamber of Commerce

Leave a comment
The goal of our comment policy is to make the comments section a vibrant yet civil space. Treat each other with respect — even the people you disagree with. Whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *