The reputation of The Keg of Evanston may finally be catching up with it.

The city’s Liquor Control Board this morning heard that 17 people were arrested for underage drinking at the bar on Jan. 6, and that the very next night police were able to make three more arrests there for the same offense.

Board members unanimously agreed the problem at the bar at 810 Grove St. is nothing new.

“The word is out,” board member Dick Peach said, “that The Keg is the place to go if you’re under age.”

Top: Keg attorney Todd Stephens and owner Tom Migon. Above: Liquor board members Marion Macbeth, Patrick Hughes and Byron Wilson.

Board member Patrick Hughes told bar owner Tom Migon, “High school kids from as far away as Lake Bluff and Highland Park drive to Evanston knowing there’s a good chance they’re going to be able to get into your place.”

And Mayor Elizabeth Tisdahl said, “There are plenty of other bars along the way, but they come to The Keg.”

City attorney Grant Farrar placed in evidence screen shots from a Twitter account in the bar’s name that he said promoted underage drinking there as well as reviews from Yelp that suggest no one over 21 would to visit the place. “Dark, dirty and borderline disgusting,” was one typical comment.

Migon and his attorney, Todd Stephens, claimed to have never heard about the Twitter account and said they had no control over what someone might write about the bar on Yelp.

While the hearing was underway whoever does control the Twitter account posted a message saying it was unaffiliated with the bar, and shortly thereafter the account was deleted.

The last messages from the “Keg of Evanston” Twitter account.

Stephens said the bar requires patrons to show two forms of identification and complained that fake ID cards produced in China are now available for a little as $75 and are very hard to detect.

Chief Eddington looks at fake ID cards presented to him by Stephens.

But Police Chief Richard Eddington said the multiple ID requirement was meaningless — because the bar accepts credit cards or similar items that provide no photo and no proof of age as the second ID.

Eddington said The Keg is unique among Evanston bars.

“The rest of the establishments are checked periodically, and we’ve never had this type of volume of problems in other establishments,” Eddington said.

Stephens offered to turn over to police computer hard drives with images the bar captures of IDs that patrons provide, but Eddington said he had “no interest in devoting public resources for what you should be doing to police your own business.”

Mayor Elizabeth Tisdahl ordered the bar closed for two days in 2010 after an underage patron who’d been drinking was injured in a fight at the bar.

And in June 2005, then mayor Lorraine Morton suspended The Keg’s liquor license for seven days after 22-year-old Robert Gresham of Evanston was shot and killed inside the bar. Antoine Hill, of 1716 Payne St., who was 19 at the time of the incident, was later convicted of shooting Gresham and was sentenced to 18 years in prison.

Under the city’s liquor code the mayor could suspend or revoke the bar’s license.

Migon, who has owned the bar for two decades, said late in the hearing, “I’m sweating right now. I’ve got two little girls. This is my livelihood.”

He compared the time since he received notice of the hearing to “like waking up with a cancer in my brain. I’m worried and scared.”

Mayor Elizabeth Tisdahl gets to decide the bar’s fate.

Tisdahl said, “The last thing I want to do is close an Evanston business, but you have to give me some assurance that conditions will change, and I haven’t heard it yet today.”

Tisdahl, who also serves as the city’s liquor commissioner, said she would announce her decision on what to do about the bar by Tuesday. 

Excerpt from the Evanston City code


(A) Violation; Hearing: The local liquor control commissioner may revoke or suspend any license issued by him if he determines the licensee has violated any of the provisions of this chapter, or any applicable rules or regulations established by the local liquor control commissioner or the state commission which is not inconsistent with law. However, no such license shall be so revoked or suspended except after a public hearing by the local liquor control commissioner with a three (3) day written notice to the licensee affording the licensee an opportunity to appear and defend. If the local liquor control commissioner has reason to believe that any continued operation of a particular licensed premises will immediately threaten the welfare of the community, he may, upon the issuance of a written order stating the reason for such conclusion and without notice or hearing, order the licensed premises closed for not more than seven (7) days, giving the licensee an opportunity to be heard during that period, except that if such licensee shall also be engaged in the conduct of another business or businesses on the licensed premises, such order shall not be applicable to such other business or businesses.

(B) Reuse Of Premises: When any license shall have been revoked for any cause, no license shall be granted to any person for the period of one year thereafter for the conduct of business of selling alcoholic liquor in the premises described in such revoked license.

Bill Smith is the editor and publisher of Evanston Now.

Join the Conversation


  1. Tom Migon

    Doesn't Mr. Migon own another bar?  I wonder if he has had similar violations there?

    This problem has been going on for years at the Keg…what does the Mayor need to think about?  It seems clear cut to me!

  2. The Keg has always been the

    The Keg has always been the place for underage drinking. I went there in high school… in the 70's!

  3. Don’t do it

    Let's not let jobs in Evanston get killed. Work with The Keg to fix this problem. There must be a creative and collaborative solution to this issue. Perhaps they could hire off-duty law enforcement officers to help with security.

  4. Could The Keg ever change?

    It's true. Even when I was a teenager we knew our IDs (fake) would always be easy to pass at The Keg. That was 20 years ago!  So yeah,  I'd say the the word is out about The Keg being the best place to go if ypu're underage. It's ancient news.

  5. The Keg

    Listen.  Is it criminal?  Yea for sure.  They were serving underage people for decades.  But they at least made people show something that half passed for an excuse to let you in.


    Whats stupid is the cops have known about this for least as long as they have been serving underage (students).  It's a BLOCK away from the police department, and they've been padding their DUI arrests for years by sitting around the parking area for this bar and all the others around the corner.  Watching people walk out drunk and pulling them over immediately.

    I guarantee that the majority of those arrests have been underage.  And they never raised a red flag about it till now?   Thats the police departments fault.

    Northwestern students are informed of this place from their first days at school.  Northwesterns police department knows all about it as well.  Have they informed the city council?  Nope.


    Tom should get his liscense pulled for sure.  But they should revamp both of these police dpeartments.  A major review of old arrests should be made and more than a few cops jobs should be ended as well.

    Massive failure all around.  Guessing some uninformed higherup finally sniffed wind of this and ran this sting to finally do something that should have happened 25 years ago.

    This is nothing students haven't known since I was in highschool at ETHS in the 80's.


  6. The Keg of Evanston

    TheKkeg of Evanston has been around forever and there is no new reason to shut it down. I love The Keg and have very fond memories of walking that fine establishment in high school, however none of walking out…

  7. The Keg Evanston

    Underage drinking is a problem in most college/university towns. Why not communicate with them and find out some "best practices."   I read in an article that the owners are willing to install additional safeguards, cooperate any way they can, to prevent the underaged from accessing the premises. 

Leave a comment
The goal of our comment policy is to make the comments section a vibrant yet civil space. Treat each other with respect — even the people you disagree with. Whenever possible, provide links to credible documentary evidence to back up your factual claims.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *